The big three no.1 Heart disease
In new mini-series, Robert Fieldhouse
takes a look at the main threats to our health in the HAART era
People
with HIV in the developed world expect to have a near-normal life span, thanks
to antiretroviral therapy. But we are still more likely to get sick from cancers
or lung, liver or heart disease.
We are at increased risk of heart disease for several reasons.
HIV and its treatment leads to abnormal rises and falls in blood fats that
make strokes, heart disease and diabetes more likely.
The DAD study found compelling evidence for a link between HIV and treatment
and increased risk of heart disease. This study combined results from several
US and European HIV treatment centres and found increased risk of cardiovascular
disease for each year spent on antiretroviral therapy.
This sounds scary, as most of us will probably have to take HIV medication
for the rest of our lives. But researchers also found traditional risk factors
such as smoking, age, gender and elevated blood lipids, were more significant
contributors to this increased risk than HIV or its treatment.
Some risks can be reduced easily like stopping smoking. But some, like our
age, we are stuck with. So it makes sense to change the things we can.
A downside of a near-normal life expectancy from improved treatments is that
we are prone to complications associated with aging like everyone else, and
heart disease is one of these.
Right from the start
Any fears about heart disease should not make you delay starting HIV therapy
if you need it. Newer combos are more ‘lipid-friendly’ than drugs
of old. A large study following people with HIV found no link between starting
therapy with a protease inhibitor (PI) or a non-nuke (NNRTI) and heart problems.
The DAD study is still ongoing. As we begin to avoid raised lipids with newer
drugs in better combos, and start to use extra meds that reduce elevated lipids,
studies like DAD should start to show a decrease in the risk of heart disease.
Don’t get too hung up on the increased risk of heart disease; plenty
of studies show antiretroviral therapy means fewer deaths for many reasons.
Using some ritonavir boosted PI has been associated with increases in all
lipids, especially triglycerides. Among PIs, atazanavir, even when used with
ritonavir, appears more lipid-friendly than other boosted PIs.
First-generation nukes
Use of nukes, historically regarded as lipid-neutral, can also affect lipid
levels. Clinical trials have shown older nukes such as d4T are more likely
to elevate triglycerides than newer drugs.
| Drug classes and individual drugs Protease Inhibitors ritonavir (full dose) (Norvir) lopinavir/ritonavir (Kaletra) indinavir (Crixivan) nelfinavir (Viracept) fosamprenavir (Telzir) tipranavir (Aptivus) saquinavir (Invirase), atazanavir (Reyataz) NRTIs AZT (Retrovir) d4T (Zerit) tenofovir (Viread), abacavir (Ziagen), 3TC (Epivir), FTC (Emtriva) NNRTIs efavirenz (Sustiva) nevirapine (Viramune) |
Lipid effects Increased TC/TG Increased TC/TG Increased TC/TG Increased LDL/TG; decrease HDL Increased TC/TG; increase HDL Increased TC/TG No significant effect No significant effect Mild increase TC/TG Increased TC/TG No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect Mild increase TC/HDL/LDL; increased HDL Increased HDL |
Glucose effects Increased insulin Increased insulin Increased insulin No significant effect No significant effect Not known No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect Increased insulin No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect No significant effect |
LDL = low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; HDL = high-density lipoprotein
cholesterol; TG = triglycerides; TC total cholesterol
Non-nuke protection
Combos including non-nukes (NNRTIs) like nevirapine or efavirenz are largely
considered ‘lipid-neutral’. A majority of people starting therapy
see their lipids rise. This may be due to the levels normalising after they
have fallen during the months or years of living with a detectable viral load.
People starting with nevirapine (Viramune) typically see larger increases
in their ‘protective’ HDL cholesterol levels and larger decreases
in their total cholesterol compared with people starting therapy with efavirenz
(Sustiva). But the clinical significance of these differences is unknown.
If you are male, older and a smoker (a significant heart disease risk factor)
you would be wise to discuss lipid-friendlier drugs with your doctor to minimise
risk to your heart. People in the UK typically start therapy with two nukes
(NRTIs) and a non-nuke (NNRTI).
Stub it out
Modifying your lifestyle can reduce your risk of developing heart disease
or having a heart attack.
Studies show people living with HIV are more likely to be smokers than the
general population. Smoking ups your risk of heart disease and is linked to
faster HIV disease progression. Stopping will have a greater positive impact
on your heart attack risk than taking lipid-lowering pills.
Get
active
Several studies show people living with HIV who increase their physical activity
can improve their lipids, particularly reducing triglyceride levels. Try swimming,
cycling, aerobics, running and weight training (sometimes called resistance
training). Alternatively, yoga can help maintain muscle tone and suppleness
with the added benefit of its meditative and relaxing qualities.
Tackle your diet
Special diets have not been evaluated methodically in groups of people living
with HIV but clinical experience shows the benefits of dieting, as in the
general population, tend to be transient and modest.
Research shows combining a healthy diet and regular exercise can lead to metabolic
improvements good enough to reduce your risk of heart disease.
In developed countries with access to treatments, people living with HIV are
now more likely to become obese than experience wasting. Increased body mass
is a contributor to increased lipids, which ups your risk of heart disease.
Hep C co-infection
Recent Canadian research showed people co-infected with HIV and hepatitis
C are less likely than people with HIV alone to develop lipid abnormalities
during HIV combination therapy. They are also less likely to need lipid-lowering
therapy. This benefit is lost if interferon therapy clears the hep C virus.
Switching drugs
A number of published clinical trials show that switching from less lipid-friendly
drugs to those with a more favourable lipid profile is safe. But you need
to discuss potential risks such as you losing control of your HIV with your
doctor.
Modest improvements in ‘bad’ LDL cholesterol and ‘good’
HDL cholesterol and triglycerides can be expected if you switch from a PI
to an NNRTI-containing combo. Switching to three nukes (NRTIs) is not recommended
as studies question the antiviral potency and durability of this approach.
If you need to stick with PIs, switching within the same class may improve
raised lipids. The same applies to some drugs from the nuke (NRTI) class.
Should I take other meds?
Some of us may need additional medications to reduce elevated cholesterol
or triglycerides. Over the past few years, many of these have been tested
in people living with HIV. See the table below for more information.
Final thought
If you have anxieties about heart disease, ask your doctor for more information
about how your risks could be reduced. No one approach is a magic bullet.
You’ll probably have to try different strategies to see which you respond
to best.
• This article has been supported by an educational grant from Gilead
Sciences Ltd
Drugs and supplements
| What is it? Statins Fibrates Niacin Fish oil Ezetimibe |
What effect can I expect? • Reduction in LDL cholesterol • Pravastatin, atorvastatin, fluvastatin are preferred drugs in HIV • Limited data on rosuvastatin • Lovastatin, simvastatin; contraindicated with PIs • Reduction in elevated TGs • Modestly improve LDL and HDL cholesterol • Slight increase in markers of insulin resistance • Around 40% reduction in TGs in one study • Can be used with fibrates • May decrease LDL cholesterol by around 20% • Limited data, larger study due to report in 2008 |
PIs = protease inhibitors; NRTIs = nucleoside reverse transcriptase
inhibitors;
NNRTIs = nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors; TC = total cholesterol;
HDL = high-density cholesterol; LDL = low-density cholesterol; TG = triglycerides